Christmas at the Corey’s
Princess Diana was not God
Hamilton Nolan wrote a piece on gawker entitled “Steve Jobs is not God”. His argument is simple:
Real outpourings of public grief should be reserved for those people who lived life so heroically and selflessly that they stand as shining examples of love for all of humanity.
People like, for example, the Rev. Fred Shuttlesworth, who—along with his family—was bombed, beaten, and stabbed during his years of principled activism in the US civil rights movement. Shuttlesworth died yesterday, the same day as Steve Jobs. He did not die a billionaire.
Until recently (by which I mean yesterday) I could have written this article myself. I had nothing but contempt for people who got very demonstrative about the death of a celebrity. I recall when Michael Jackson died; I could not have cared less. ”Why are all these people crying?” I said.
I recall the day Princess Diana died back in 1997. 5 days later Mother Thersea died. The rant I went on (with my friends, as it was 1997 and the “blog” had not really been invented) was precisely what Hamilton is arguing in his article. Why are we so worried about a Princess when an actual saint has died? What a shallow waste of time all of you are. This is ridiculous. Amy Winehouse, John Lennon, Kurt Cobain. Nothing. I could not have cared less.
Then Steve Jobs died yesterday. And I understood. It almost seems silly. it certainly seems silly to the 1997 me. That I could be moved by the death of a stranger was an alien concept. When I read Dan Benjamin on twitter saying he had heard of of Steve Job’s death my chest tightened. My eyes started to sting. My shoulders slumped and I looked around to tell someone, but I was alone. So this is what it felt like for some people when Michael Jackson died.
What i realized yesterday is that people can’t help but invest their dreams in someone else. Creating is hard. It is the most difficult and most valuable thing that a human can do: make something they feel they needed to make, and put it out into the world. And most of us don’t. That is not a criticism, but a fact. So when we see someone who is doing what we wish we had done, or could do, we latch on to them. They become our proxy in a way, and we attach our self worth to them. I think this is only human.
I suspect that Nolan Hamilton just hasn’t had the right person die yet.
